Just learned that my high school crush was in love with me for years - and is now an incel
He was shy and quiet but had such a big lovely caring personality and was great to talk to, the type of guy who always had something interesting to say and also great at listening and making you feel valued
We were great friends for a while, I caught feelings, and thought he might like me too. I had a mutual friend tell him I was interested in him and 100% would say yes if he asked me out. The friend said he wasn't interested in me, so I started drifting away from him, he remained friends and would sometimes reach out and try to be closer friends but I distanced to try and get over him and eventually we didn't talk for years
I was chatting with another old friend recently and she mentioned that this guy told her he had a crush on me ever since like the first month or so of us talking, and that he'd maintained feelings for the entire time she knew him
I reached out to him about this and he's absolutely insistent that I just had my other friend ask him to ask me out as a joke or as a way to see if he genuinely valued me as a friend and wasn't that type of guy who only befriends women as a backdoor to romance. He insists there's no way I'd ever have dated him and no way anyone else would either. Now I'm stuck on him again, imagining the past decade with him rather than a string of failed relationships, but there was probably nothing I could do anyway. But I'm so pissed. We could have been a good thing and even now, apart from the bitterness of being alone, he's still nice. I hate that I'm thinking about him again